What We Learned This Weekend – Week 12



The 2009 college football is drawing to a close and conclusions are sliding into place.  With two weeks to go in the regular season, Week 12 told us the following:

1.  Whether postseason possibilities fall into place in the ACC.

2.  Who gets the upper hand during Rivalry Week in the Big Ten.

3.  Whether the Pac 10 Conference race tends toward sanity or chaos.

4.  Who will compete in the Big XII Championship Game.

5.  Who are set to emerge as the contestants in the Conference USA Championship Game.

Continue reading ‘What We Learned This Weekend – Week 12’ »

Five Things We Will Learn This Weekend – Week 12



1.  Whether postseason possibilities fall into place in the ACC.

2.  Who gets the upper hand during Rivalry Week in the Big Ten.

3.  Whether the Pac 10 Conference race tends toward sanity or chaos.

4.  Who will compete in the Big XII Championship Game.

5.  Who are set to emerge as the contestants in the Conference USA Championship Game.

Continue reading ‘Five Things We Will Learn This Weekend – Week 12’ »

Pick ‘Em – Week 12



This week’s guest picker is Mike Cheyne.  Mike is an American Studies doctoral candidate at the University of Minnesota. After getting an undergrad degree at Division II powerhouse Grand Valley State University, he agonized his way through quietly underachieving MAC years at Western Michigan University to get a Master’s. Now, he is at an another underachieving school in a bigger pond. Life’s grand.

Week 11 was an improvement of sorts as everyone did better than average.  Fred won the week with a sweet 7-1 record. The only miss was Stanford-USC, which everyone muffed. Right behind Fred was our guest picker Ricky.  DanGo remains our leader, six games ahead of DanGr.

Author Chris DanGo DanGr Fred Guest
Last Week / YTD 4-4 / 50-38 4-4 / 57-31 5-3 / 51-37 7-1 / 49-39 6-2 / 46-42
North Carolina (+3) at Boston College North Carolina North Carolina North Carolina Boston College North Carolina
Connecticut (+7.5) at Notre Dame Notre Dame Notre Dame Connecticut Notre Dame Notre Dame
#8 Louisiana State (+3) at Mississippi Mississippi Louisiana State Louisiana State Mississippi Mississippi
#14 Penn State (-3.5) at Michigan State Michigan State Penn State Penn State Penn State Michigan State
#16 Wisconsin (-4) at Northwestern Wisconsin Wisconsin Wisconsin Wisconsin Northwestern
#25 California (+8) at #17 Stanford California Stanford Stanford Stanford California
Kansas State (+13) at Nebraska Nebraska Nebraska Nebraska Nebraska Nebraska
#11 Oregon (-4) at Arizona Oregon Oregon Arizona Oregon Oregon

Read on for commentary and analysis.

Continue reading ‘Pick ‘Em – Week 12’ »

What We Learned This Weekend – Week 12



1.  Whether the ACC races will narrow or become more muddled. Finally, with two weeks left to impress, the twin ACC divisional races are finally approaching their conclusions.  That said, there are still at least nine teams left that have a chance to go to Tampa for the ACC Championship Game sponsored by some soda brand I am blanking out on.  Believe it or not, all twelve teams are still capable of becoming bowl eligible.  There is even a scenario in which all twelve teams can get to six or more wins.  There is no outstanding, excellent, great, or even very good team in this conference (no team has more than seven wins), but neither is there any terrible, horrible, no-good, very bad team in this conference (no team has fewer than four wins).  It is parity that rivals the NFL.  It has been and will be great fun to watch…until the eventual BCS participant gets broasted in the Orange Bowl.

The Atlantic division is, by far, the easier of the two divisions for which to lay out scenarios.  There are three games left among members of the division, and all of them involve the four teams that are still in the hunt.  That means there are eight different scenarios.  In all scenarios, the outright or tied division champion has at least five wins, so Clemson and North Carolina State have no chance to even tie for the division, much less win it.

Four of the scenarios result in Maryland heading to Tampa.  Maryland also has the only two scenarios in which someone wins the division outright at 6-2 and is the victor of the only three-way scenario by way of their superior division record.  Boston College is the big winner in two of the scenarios, while Florida State and Wake Forest each have one scenario in which they win the division.

Not surprisingly, Maryland has the easiest path to Tampa.  Win their remaining two games, and they are in.  Depending on the result of the third game between Boston College and Wake Forest, they could clinch as early as the fans storming the field at Byrd Stadium after they defeat Florida State.  The three other teams will be eliminated with a loss this coming weekend, while Maryland would stay alive with a Wake Forest win earlier in the day.

The Coastal division is much more monstrous logistically, with seven games among five teams leading to 128 scenarios.  The only thing we know for sure is that Duke cannot win the division.  The simplest set of scenarios is if Miami wins its final two games and wins the division outright at 6-2.  Whether Miami can clinch the division in Week 13 will be revealed in my next “Five Things…” column.

2.  Whether powers across the nation can avoid a letdown in this light week. For the most part, the answer was a resounding yes.  In the only game matching ranked teams, one of those ranked teams is ranked no longer after a 56-6 defeat.  Florida’s annihilation of South Carolina was the worst loss Steve Spurrier has ever endured as a college coach.  There were only three upsets among members of the top 25, and the bacchanalia that is the ACC accounted for two of them.  The third was Houston’s 70-30 demolition of former Top Mid-Major contestant Tulsa.  The closest call was in the bayou as LSU manufactured an insane 37-0 scoring binge after allowing Troy to go up 31-3 on them at Tiger Stadium.

Among the four games under watch, all four passed their challenges with varying degrees of flight of the colors:

Alabama passed its 90 mile test against Mississippi State with flying colors by scoring 25 consecutive points after the Bulldogs went up 7-5.

USC passed its trip to the Farm with gliding colors by outscoring Stanford 28-6 after the two teams fought to a 17-17 halftime tie.

Georgia passed its Auburn test with wounded duck colors by needing a fourth quarter touchdown and a defensive stop in the last minute to survive 17-13.

Ohio State passed its Illinois test with flying colors courtesy of an Illibucking 30-20 win over Illinois that was not as close as the final score indicates.

3.  Whether powers across the nation can avoid a letdown in this light week…Big 12 Edition. I present more of the same chrono-avian imagery in the three games I highlighted in flyover country.  Texas passed their Kansas test with flying colors by going up 21-0 and cruising to a 35-7 win.  Missouri passed their trip to Jack Trice Stadium with flying colors through their 52-20 rout of Iowa State that punched their second ticket to Kansas City.  The first ticket is in two weeks when they play Kansas at Arrowhead.  Finally, Oklahoma State passed its Buffalo hunt with gliding colors with a 30-17 win over Colorado.  Bring on Texas Tech-Oklahoma!

4.  Whether Navy can put to rest talk of needing another 43 years to defeat Notre Dame again. With about two and a half minutes left, it appeared Navy was doomed to needing another historically bad year in South Bend to triumph over the Fighting Irish.  The 27-7 scoreline at the time was an indication that Notre Dame had just dominated the Midshipmen in the second half after a relatively even first half.  The fact that Notre Dame played a particular poor game lent even more to the credence that the Irish won on talent alone, including their trio of running backs.  But then Notre Dame played its worst two and a half minutes of the game.

In that magical 150 seconds, Notre Dame gave up a 20+ yard rushing touchdown, a 50+ pass that set up a touchdown, two onside kicks, and was set to complete the collapse by allowing Navy to penetrate their end zone for the third time in three minutes.  Luckily for the Irish, Navy’s last gasp drive fell apart and they escaped from M&T Bank Stadium with a 27-21 win.  While the talent differential will continue to be large, Navy will always have a chance to win if Notre Dame is playing poorly, and the game will be entertaining nonetheless.

5.  Whether Utah will remain the frontrunner to become America’s Next Top Mid-Major. The answer is yes after their 63-14 spanking of San Diego State.  All that remains between the Utes and the BCS is the Holy War with BYU, whose battlefield this year is Salt Lake City.  Thanks to the Mountain West Conference’s lousy television package, only those people who receive The Mtn. will get to watch the Utes and Cougars in action.  Chain chain chain.  Chain of fools.

In case Utah drops the ball, Boise State is ready to pick it up and run to the WAC’s third consecutive BCS appearance.  Boise State continued their dominance of the WAC with a 45-10 win over Idaho at the Kibbie Dome.  Among the also-rans, TCU sat at home and played the fiddle while BYU went to Colorado Springs and removed Air Force from a chance at the conference crown with a 38-24 victory.

The hot action is coming up sooner than you think because Ball State is about to hit the meat of its schedule.  The first step by Brady Hoke, Nate Davis, Miquale Lewis, and the crew is a trip to Mount Pleasant to face Central Michigan.  The Chippewas feature dual threat quarterback Dan LeFevour, who strutted his stuff against Georgia and has led CMU to the MAC Championship Game the previous two seasons.  The Cardinals are taking a shot at getting to 11-0 for the first time in school history, as well as denying the Chippewas the trip to Detroit they would earn by besting BSU.

Five Things We Will Learn This Weekend – Week 12



1.  Whether the ACC races will narrow or become even more muddled. Virginia Tech was set to virtually eliminate Miami from the ACC Coastal division race, but something happened on the way to Dolphin Stadium: Miami turned out to be the better team and handed Virginia Tech their third loss.  The result of that game now opens the race up once again.  The immediate beneficiary of the Hurricane victory?  North Carolina.

Thanks to their earlier win over the Hurricanes, the Tar Heels now control their own destiny.  They finish with the two sixth-place teams, North Carolina State and Duke, so five conference victories is a given.  The last major obstacle is this weekend’s tilt at Maryland.  A win effectively puts the division title in their grasp; a loss hands Miami control of their destiny.  It is a game of hot potato, in the conference no one wants to win, and Georgia Tech, while virtually eliminated, wants to challenge the trajectory of the potato when they host Miami in another Thursday night showcase.

The Atlantic division is almost as muddled.  Nothing has changed in terms of the standings, but Boston College can start their late charge by knocking off Florida State in Tallahassee.  A loss ensures the Eagles will be spoilers at best.  By comparison, Maryland’s game against North Carolina has no implications beyond the win total.  Wake Forest will be pulling for North Carolina to knock off the Terps while they attempt to put down North Carolina State.  With win and a Maryland loss, the Demon Deacons would be able to clinch the division title next week against Boston College.

2.  Whether powers across the nation can avoid a letdown in this light week. Aside from South Carolina-Florida, there are no games between ranked teams this week.  That means those high flying teams that are playing will be trying to avoid being grounded by a thirsty underdog.  Lets take a look and play oddsmaker with some games that could send shock waves throughout conference races and even the national championship race:

Mississippi State at Alabama.  The Maroon Bulldogs are having an ugly season, but there is always the possibility of them rising up and Crooming a high-flying opponent.  None so much as Alabama, which has lost the last two games in the 90 Mile Drive series.  That being said, Miss. State is the worst team in the SEC West and the Crimson Tide players will have the fear of Nick Saban’s wrath should their season be bludgeoned by Croom’s crew.  Chances of an upset: 1%

USC at Stanford.  The Trojans are crushing and killing their way through the schedule, while Stanford is just trying to become bowl eligible for the first time in the Jim Harbaugh era.  The first really big win of the Jim Harbough era was last year’s win in the Coliseum, which was the largest point spread upset ever.  He would love to pull off another surprise, but there is no way Pete Carroll’s side overlooks the Cardinal this year.  They will want revenge for last year.  They also have the fear that if they come up empty, their BCS streak is over.  Chances of an upset: 12%

Georgia at Auburn.  The War Tiger Eagles need to defeat one of their hated rivals in order to go bowling this year.  That will be a tall order against this very good Bulldog team.  Auburn has been very mediocre this season.  Their offense has been offensive by SEC standards.  Their defense has played valiantly, but it takes 2 1/2 units to be formidable.  So this is an easy Georgia win, right?  You just never know in a rivalry game.  Chances of an upset: 20%

Ohio State at Illinois.  This game is about stealing back the turtle.  Not Testudo, but Illibuck.  The Fighting Illini came into Columbus and earned their signature win of 2007, a 28-21 Juicing of the Buckeyes.  Illinois has had a forgettable season, but that can chance in a hurry with a win over The Ohio State University.  Meanwhile, the Buckeyes are trying to stay in contention for a BCS at-large bid.  They want to avoid a shaky moment that will cause their postseason aspirations to slip to the Capital One Bowl.  Chances of an upset: 40%

3.  Whether powers across the nation can avoid a letdown in this light week…Big 12 Edition. This week is quite a bore with everyone looking forward to the ginormous showdown between Texas Tech and Oklahoma that will either decide the South’s participant in the Big 12 Championship Game, or throw the division race into a potential circle of death.  So we will play oddsmaker once again with some games that could be upset specials.

Texas at Kansas.  Early in the year, this looked like a game to circle on the calendar, but Kansas turned out to be quite pedestrian this year.  They can change that perception in a hurry by upsetting the Longhorns, who have their target on a national title or, at the least, a BCS bid.  Can the Jayhawks dial up some of last year’s magic?  Can Todd Reesing have the game of his career?  Can the defense play like it is 2007?  Chances of an upset: 15%

Missouri at Iowa State.  This is the closest thing Iowa State has to an in-conference rivalry.  The two teams fight for the Telephone Trophy, an old rotary phone on a stick used to commemorate some incompetence by a telephone company.  Missouri can clinch the Big 12 North title with a win (and a Kansas loss), while the Cyclones can get their first significant win of the thus-far-forgetful Gene Chizik era.  The Tigers have been crushing and killing through the Big 12 North and should do the same with impotent I-State, but you never know in a rivalry game.  Chances of an upset: 4%

Oklahoma State at Colorado.  The Cowboys are now playing for the second tier bowls, those celebrating Holidays and Cotton.  To ensure they make it to San Diego or Dallas, they need to take care of business in Boulder in their last road game of the season.  Colorado is just trying to become bowl eligible in a season that has seen high hopes get crushed by poor play.  A win in their final home game of the season avoids having to take their show on the road to Lincoln to try to wrest a win from Mad Bo Pelini.  Chances of an upset: 30%

4.  Whether Navy can put to rest talk of needing another 43 years to defeat Notre Dame again. It took Notre Dame’s worst season in…forever to provide the golden opportunity the Midshipmen needed to finally end the longest series losing streak in NCAA history.  It took three overtimes, but Navy got the job done in South Bend.  The Irish now take their show to Baltimore to try to return to normalcy.  The Irish are much better this year.  Since everyone is expecting Notre Dame to resume dominance, a win does nothing except earn them bowl eligibility.  Paul Johnson has moved on, but it is unclear at this time how this year’s Navy team compares to last year’s.  A second consecutive win over the Irish removes any doubt that 2008 Navy is da bomb, and that this series can be competitive again.

5.  Whether Utah will remain the frontrunner to become America’s Next Top Mid-Major. After last week’s thrilling 13-10 win over TCU to squash the Horned Frogs’ BCS hopes and boost their own, the Utes get a respite in the form of a trip to lovely Southern California to face a lousy San Diego State team whose head coach will probably not keep that title for Long.  Could it be a letdown game?  Of course!  Will they get caught in the sandwich between TCU and BYU?  No.  Utah has had its way with bad teams all season and this one will be no different.

The team in the on deck circle also has a beatdown in its future.  Boise State travels up US 95 to face their in-state rival Idaho in the totally awesome Kibbie Dome.  In case you cannot read the irony, it will be the Broncos administering the beatdown, unless Idaho has a lights out game, which is just as likely as Jessica Simpson’s bison to grow wings.

In the mid-week special, Ball State achieved a 10-0 record for the first time in school history after a closer-than-expected game against Miami University.  Bo Derek would be proud; David Letterman certainly is.  The Cardinals lettermen now face the two toughest games of the season in the next two mid-week specials: two-thirds of Directional Michigan!  Full coverage coming in the next “What We Learned” column.

Among the teams that are hanging by a thread, TCU has the week off before they finish their season against Air Force.  Speaking of Air Force, they host BYU this week.  The Zoomies have a chance to knock BYU’s probability of a BCS bid from infinitesimal to zero.

Pick ‘Em – Week 12



Hey – what’s that? I’m not so bad at picking games after all. We’ve got a tie for second place now.

Author Chris DanGo DanGr Fred
Last Week 3-4 5-2 4-3 4-3
Year to Date (37-40) (42-35) (42-35) (45-32)
Boston College (+6.5) at #19 Florida State Florida State Florida State Florida State Florida State
South Carolina (+22.5) at #4 Florida Florida Florida Florida Florida
#16 North Carolina (-3) at Maryland Maryland Maryland Maryland North Carolina
Minnesota (+13.5) at Wisconsin Wisconsin Wisconsin Wisconsin Wisconsin
Virginia Tech (+3.5) at Miami (FL) Virginia Tech Miami Miami Virginia Tech
UCF (+7) at Marshall UCF Marshall Marshall Marshall
Notre Dame (-4) at Navy (Baltimore, MD) Notre Dame Navy Navy Notre Dame

Boston College (+6.5) at #19 Florida State, Saturday 8:00pm ABC
Chris: Can anyone name any players on Boston College? I’m guessing DanGr could, but I can’t.
[Ed.: DanGr chose not to respond to this particular challenge, but I will: Kevin Challenger.]

South Carolina (+22.5) at #4 Florida, Sat 3:30pm CBS
DanGr: Does this seem familiar? They were in the exact same situation two years ago, twiddling their thumbs waiting for the SEC Championship Game. They ended up a botched field goal away from their national championship dreams being crushed in The Swamp by the Cocks. Do not be surprised if this is another close one, but the Gators will ultimately prevail.

#16 North Carolina (-3) at Maryland, Saturday 3:30pm ABC/ESPN
DanGo: There’s no “football science” in this pick. Maryland’s playing a a ranked team at home, thus.
Fred: Maryland is the Herschel Walker of college football. Not the dominating, run through eight brick walls and several small children actual player Herschel Walker, but you never know which Herschel you’re going to get Herschel Walker.

Minnesota (+13.5) at Wisconsin, Saturday 3:30pm ABC/ESPN
DanGo: Both of these teams have had a surprising season; Minnesota in a good way, Wisconsin in a not so good way. The Gophers have been surprising, but the loss to Michigan last week was a demoralizing blow, and the Badgers look to be too tough to stop.

Virginia Tech (+3.5) at Miami (FL), Thursday 8:00pm ESPN
Chris: Robert Marve continues running in place by throwing a couple picks, and Va Tech gets just enough offense to win.
DanGo: While I’m cheering for the Hokies the whole time in this one, I’m going to have to pick against them. The offense has still been stagnant, and even with a questionable return from Tyrod Taylor, the Hokies have too many question marks to play 60 minutes with a resurgent group of Hurricanes.

UCF (+7) at Marshall, Saturday 4:30 CSS
Chris: UCF has the worst offense in Division I, but Joe Burnett will get a pick and make a special teams play to get the Knights over. Bet on a combined under of 29 points.
PS–boy does George O’Leary suck.
DanGr: George O’Leary not only did not play college football, he also did not earn a Master’s in Education from NYU. Zing! That is besides the point. Face it, this Golden Knights team is as tarnished as O’Leary’s reputation. They are going to get spanked in Huntington against a Herd that wants to put pressure on East Carolina in the C-USA East race.

Notre Dame (-4) at Navy (Baltimore, MD), Saturday 12:00pm CBS
DanGr: If I pick against Navy again, my fiancée will exile herself to the couch.
Chris: DanGR, your fiancee needs to start practicing now to be a wife: YOU get exiled to the couch, not her.
DanGr: My fiancee will be no ordinary wife. I paid for the bed, so it is she who leaves. She agrees with me on this point.