What’s the best way to be completely wrong and have everyone tell you so? Make your own top 25!
1. Florida – The recovery of Tebow is very important for Florida. While I could make this a joke entry with only painfully obvious statements, it’s important to understand just how serious a concussion is.
This being said, Florida should be just fine without Tebow. I’m unsure if they’ll be capable of winning a national championship, but they’ll definitely be a force against anyone they play.
2. Texas – It’s amazing how little I’ve heard about Texas this year. There’s been talk about how great Florida is, and how USC was shockingly beaten by Washington, and BYU beating Oklahoma, and Ohio State “choking” away another big game (despite that being what could have been the best marquee performance since beating Michigan to get into the BCS National Championship game a few years ago), and Texas has, amazingly, been overlooked with Colt McCoy, the rest of that great offense and a great defense. Texas will be a force to reckon with, and if Tebow’s out for an extended period, they could take over as the #1 team in the nation.
3. Alabama – I didn’t believe in Alabama a year ago. I thought that, inevitably, they would lose as the season progressed. To Georgia, or LSU, or Ole Miss. To somebody. By the time they lost to Florida, it was anti-climactic. Of course they’d lose; I’d been saying it all season.
I don’t feel this way this year. I’m worried about Alabama playing at Ole Miss, and hosting LSU isn’t a walk in the park. There’s always the chance of other bumps in the road, just because of the nature of the SEC, but I’ve bought into this team this year. I’m pretty sure Nick Saban could take a crate of PlayDoh and 15 kula rings and put together a team that could go 11-1 in the SEC.
4. LSU – Unfortunately, I am not sure about LSU being here in the long run. They have a very talented team, and I feel like they could win any conference undefeated if it wasn’t the SEC or the Big 12. But they visit Georgia, Alabama and Ole Miss, not to mention Florida. They could very easily lose all four of those games; they could just as easily win those. I don’t know what to do with this team at this point, but next weekend is going to show a lot.
5. USC – If USC had a QB with experience and two good shoulders, the thought of them playing Florida would be amazing. As it is, USC has one of the best defenses and a great running attack. With their normal “lose to an inferior Pac-10 team” thing out of the way, they should be fine the rest of the way. The only true test they have remaining is California.
Also, may I note how ridiculous it was for Washington to reach #24 in the AP poll? They went winless last year, didn’t play particularly well before facing USC and lost immediately after Stanford. AP voters have approximately the same attention span as a kitten faced with a shoelace attach – oh look over there!
6. Oklahoma – This assumes Sam Bradford returns with the ability to lift his hand above his shoulder soon and can play against Texas. Without him, they face a difficult time. They still have a strong defense and a developing offense. Playing at Miami, hosting Baylor, facing Texas and visiting Kansas will be a test of just how they stand nationally post Bradford.
7. Iowa – I may come to regret this ranking soon, the number of times a Ferentz-led team pulled off the whole “oh we’re very good look at us oh wait we’re supposed to win more than six games?” act. But, Iowa has a defense that can carry their offense, an offense that isn’t so bad that it’ll keep them out of games. Beating both Arizona and Penn State this early in the season gives them one of the best resumes so far.
8. Boise State – This team was expected to do well this year, but I think they’ve exceeded those expectations. The Oregon win continues to look better and better, and they’ve looked really good in their other three wins so far. The only game that could be a true test is against Nevada, who they host and who have been very disappointing so far. This team may already have locked up their status as a BCS Buster, though never say never.
9. TCU – The road win at Clemson was very impressive. TCU is going to be neck and neck with BYU for the MWC this year, and will play one of the most important regular season games against them on October 24.
10. UCLA – Half of these losses could be forfeited in ten years once it’s found out what Rick Neuheisel has done, but that’s the risk you take. A road win against Tennessee and a home victory against Kansas State are two solid, if not great, wins. I doubt this ranking will hold up, but right now they deserve to be here.
11. Virginia Tech – VT’s loss to Alabama is one of the best losses I’ve seen. They really should have come away with the W, but Alabama put together a good comeback in the second half. Since then, all VT has done is beat Marshall beyond recognition, beat a rising Nebraska program and defeat the hot team of the moment, Miami. In my estimation, this is the best resume to date, and VT might have the best defense in the nation. That offense with Tyrod Taylor and Darren Evans isn’t half bad, either.
12. BYU – That win against Oklahoma was great, and the Bradford injury doesn’t dampen it much to me. I just don’t understand what happened with Florida State; FSU did not look anything close to that dynamic against Miami or USF
13. Ole Miss – They did look ugly in that loss, but I still believe in them.
14. Oklahoma State
15. Penn State
16. Notre Dame – I can’t believe I’m embracing a Notre Dame team, but here I am, and there they are.
17. Georgia
18. Miami
19. Ohio State
20. California
21. Michigan
22. South Florida
23. Georgia Tech
24. Houston – I’m just not that big on Houston. They’ve played well so far and got some big wins, but I could see them pulling an East Carolina 2008 and losing a couple of games in conference.
25. Oregon